No-Bake PB&J Pie

When I was around five years old, my earliest memory was of eating a PB&J.

My family lived in New Mexico. My mom would pick me up at noon and then make me a PB&J with diagonal cuts when we returned home.

I would eat my sandwiches while hunching over a “place mat” of a towel on the floor, with my eyes fixed on “Woody the Woodpecker,” slurping milk in between large bites.

The life was good then. Mom made sure I ate when I was hungry and that my bed was made. Cartoons, Nintendo, and biking were among the activities. The life I lived then was not as “rich” as it is today, with all the amazing people and experiences. This is why adulthood is something that I welcome with open arms.

Perhaps eating a PB&J as an adult is a silly attempt to hold onto the simplicity of childhood – a simpler time when Nintendo was king and life seemed simple.

I believe that life can be simple again, but we have to be deliberate about it. It’s not bad to eat a PB&J pie now and then to keep everything in perspective.

I can’t explain it, but the combination of peanut butter and jelly makes me feel that way. I am transported back to my childhood, even for just a few hours.

When I first set out to create this recipe, my original intention was to make a PB&J dip. You could totally make it if you want to avoid the crust. When I saw how coconut whipped cream reacts to “caramelized” dates, I knew I had to make a pie.

Coconut whipped cream on its own is delicious. When you add some peanut butter and (naturally sweeten) the date paste, it gets CRAZY. The result is the fluffiest, thickest pie filling ever.

Don’t you worry? I’ve got other ideas up my sleeves for this combination. It’s also gluten-free, dairy-free, and -free! This is some amazing stuff.

So, the pie. The assembly goes like this:

1. Make a 2-ingredient pie crust (the only baking required)2. Prepare strawberry compote, and let it cool.

3. Whip coconut cream.

4. Add date paste and peanut butter.

5. Whip again.

6. Top with cooled compote and add pie filling.

7. Chill. Eat. Start living your life.

Serving bowl with strawberry jam and a layer of fluffy peanut butter, served along with cookies, grahams, and fruit. Hello, dip genie, with 15 people lining up for seconds.



  • The crumbs from 1 sleeve of Nabisco Original Graham Crackers* or another vegan-friendly cookie/cracker (or one sleeve will yield 1 cup plus 2 Tbsp)
  • We like Earth Balance, Miyokos, or coconut oil.


  • One pound of fresh or frozen strawberries. (Or substitute another berry if you prefer // 1 pound yields approximately 3 cups)
  • Orange juice 2 tbsp ( optional for sweetness)
  • 1 tsp Chia seeds


  • Pitted dates – 1 cup (if the dates are not sticky, soak them in warm water for ten minutes and drain.
  • 1/2 Tbsp coconut oil (melted)


  • Two 14-ounce cans of full-fat coconut cream (or milk) (refrigerate overnight).
  • Salted natural creamy peanut butter, 1/2 cup


  • Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Place a large bowl of peanut butter mousse in the freezer.
  • Add the graham crackers into the food processing, and process until you get a fine meal. Add melted butter or olive oil and combine. Press evenly into the crust and transfer to a pie dish or 8×8 square dish. Bake for 10-12 mins or until golden brown. Set aside to cool.
  • In a large saucepan, cook strawberries and orange juice until they are very bubbly. Reduce heat and continue to simmer until thickened. Smash the fruit with a wooden spoon. Add chia seed (optional) and stir. Refrigerate.
  • Add dates to your food processor. Process until you get small pieces or a ball. Add a bit of coconut oil and then a small amount of warm water. Process until you get a thick paste. If desired, add a pinch or two of salt to balance the flavor. Set aside.
  • Remove coconut milk from your fridge, and scoop out the thickened cream. Leave any clear, runny liquid in the can.
  • Beat the mixture with a mixer until it becomes fluffy and forms peaks. Add peanut butter and date past until the desired taste is reached. I used 1/2 cup of peanut butter and almost all the date paste. Spread the filling evenly over the crust and chill it for up to 1 hour.
  • You can now either cut the pie into desired slices and serve it with the chilled compote OR spread the entire compote on the pie right before serving.
  • The pie will last in the refrigerator for a few weeks. After that, freeze and serve it as “icebox pie” (defrost for 15-20 minutes prior to serving).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *